Logo
Social Security Observer 11
Developments and Trends in Social Security Worldwide
Extracts from the keynote address of Hans-Horst Konkolewsky, ISSA Secretary General, at the World Social Security Forum
We have witnessed the most severe episode of global financial and economic crisis since the Great Recession of 1929. This crisis has seriously impacted the global economy, social conditions and consequently also social security schemes.

Increasing levels of unemployment and poverty have led to higher benefit expenditures, with a commensurate loss of contribution revenues and a drawing down of reserve funds. Increased investment in active labour market programmes and other responses, often as part of stimulus programmes, pushed the financial and administrative capacities of social security institutions to their limits.


WSSF Logo

World Social Security Forum 2010
The global financial and economic crisis has reaffirmed the key contribution of social security to social stability and economic recovery. The World Social Security Forum took place in Cape Town, South Africa, 29 November - 4 December 2010.

News, reports, videos and photos >>


At the same time, the financial capacity of social security systems and governments to tackle longer-term challenges related to demographic ageing, changing family structures or urbanization in the countries most affected by the crisis has been seriously diminished.

More positively, however, in a number of countries stimulus packages and other political response measures also provided important windows of opportunity to improve and extend social security benefits and services.

In this context, how can social security developments best be summarized?

Hans-Horst Konkolewsky

I believe that in spite of major difficulties and challenges, social security has been strengthened in the recent period and I would like to give you two good reasons to support this statement:

First, the societal and political status of social security has increased significantly.

During the crisis, public social security provision has acted as an unrivalled social buffer and economic stabilizer essential to maintaining economic and social stability.

Regrettably, global levels of unemployment and poverty have grown as a direct consequence of the economic downturn. However, without social security, the negative impact of the turmoil would undoubtedly have been much more serious.

Moreover, an important lesson for policy-makers worldwide is that those countries that had comprehensive social security systems in place also were the ones most able to manage its negative impact. These schemes provided policy-makers with immediate responses to help sustain aggregate demand and to offer adequate protection to those affected.

A second positive observation is that a growing number of national developments and trends are compatible with the objectives of Dynamic Social Security.

Whether prompted by the crisis, or by other socio-economic challenges and initiatives by policy-makers or social security institutions, the analysis of regional and global social security trends during the last triennium show that reforms can be classified into four cross-cutting themes.

(1) The first of these four cross-cutting trends is the effort in all regions to build high-performing and well-governed social security administrations.

Clearly in the current environment, good governance is a vitally important objective for social security organizations wherever they may be located. Delivering what is mandated and ensuring that what is delivered is responsive to the evolving needs of individuals and society is the essence of this concept.

Ensuring high quality services has been at the centre of recent reforms. Service profiles have evolved, and service channels have become more diversified. An empowered and client-oriented workforce lies at the heart of high-performing administrations.

Photo: M. Crozet/ILO

(2) The second of the four cross-cutting trends is to make social security more accessible, an issue of special relevance for the regions of Africa, Asia and the Pacific and the Americas.

As a basic human right, access to social security should be universal. However, the majority of the world’s population remains without access to comprehensive social security coverage.

Positively, a number of countries have succeeded in improving affiliation to social insurance schemes and have thereby demonstrated that rapid extension through improving compliance and enacting innovative measures for specific population groups can be achieved. Importantly, social security institutions were at the forefront of these extension efforts.

A key challenge for extension strategies has been to reach large groups of informal economy workers and their families, with migrant labour presenting special challenges in this regard. Efforts to extend access to coverage in a small number of populous and politically-prominent developing countries point to significant innovations, indicating that conventional perceptions of social protection provision are evolving.

(3) A third cross-cutting trend in recent reforms consists of broad efforts in all regions to realize sustainable social security.

Such efforts have been magnified by the impact of the financial and economic crisis.

The crisis has underlined that financially sustainable social security programmes are better able to adjust to mitigate the social risks presented by an adverse economic environment.

Yet, levels of public debt have grown and the financial health of many social security programmes has weakened.

As a result, the financial capacity to respond to future challenges such as demographic ageing and extension initiatives has been reduced. Not surprisingly, significant acceleration of reforms to guarantee financial sustainability is one of the consequences that can be observed.

Importantly, to reduce cutbacks, in particular in view of the important crisis response role social security has just played, some countries are seeking innovations in financing social security. Recent developments suggest for instance that greater integration of contributory and tax-financed social security programmes may help in guaranteeing the future financial sustainability of social security programmes. Such innovative reforms have often gone beyond the conventional relationship between contributions and benefits.

(4) This brings me to the fourth cross-cutting trend: the strengthening of proactive and preventive social security measures. This trend has been most pronounced in higher-income countries, but the diffusion of such approaches to other regions has undoubtedly accelerated.

Three years ago, I reported on the broadening of the role of social security, which is increasingly not only to protect individuals, but to also mitigate, at the earliest possible stage, the major risk factors that affect them.

It is in this cross-cutting theme where innovation has been most striking.

Proactive and preventive measures have spread across all branches of social security, aiming at risks affecting health, employment status and earnings capacity. Interventions have been applied earlier and risk-assessments of individuals and groups are becoming an important tool for effective targeting.

Positively, these four cross-cutting themes of accessibility, sustainability, proactive and preventive approaches and high-performing and well-governed social security institutions correspond to key elements of the Dynamic Social Security agenda.

However, the sheer complexity of these reforms in times of significant pressure has created tough challenges for social security administrations.


Download:

Keynote address: Developments and Trends in Social Security Worldwide
www.issa.int/content/download/136720/2784374/file/2-wssf-SG-DT-speech.pdf
[pdf, 175.18kB]

ISSA strategy for the extension of social security coverage
Social security institutions have high potential and unique opportunities to work towards the extension of coverage and they are key actors in national extension strategies
Photo: M. Crozet/ILO
(Extracts from the ISSA strategy) Social security is a human right, enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights as well as the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. Yet to date, the majority of the world’s population does not have access to adequate social security coverage.

In line with its strategic vision of Dynamic Social Security, the ISSA and its member institutions are committed to the extension of coverage and to promoting the important role of social security institutions in reaching this objective.

This document outlines the ISSA strategy. It defines the priority challenges for coverage extension, specific opportunities for social security institutions, a collaborative ISSA process for defining action plans of social security institutions to work towards extending coverage and the role of the ISSA in supporting its member institutions to implement these plans.

Priority extension challenges

The challenges related to the extension of coverage are often specific to the socio-economic situation of a country and the institutional structure of its existing social security system. In line with the priorities of its membership, the ISSA centres its strategy on actions for social security institutions to develop solutions for the following priority challenges:


Extension of health-care coverage

Timely access to quality and affordable health care is a key social security priority for ISSA member institutions. It improves individual well-being, contributes to social and economic development and has a high potential in preventing poverty.


Extension of coverage by old-age, invalidity and survivors’ pension schemes

The issue of closing the pension coverage gap has become a central concern among national policy-makers and multilateral institutions. Compulsory schemes often cover less then 25 per cent of the labour force in low-income countries and between 25 and 50 per cent in middle-income countries.


Administration of tax-financed minimum benefit schemes

High-income countries have generally implemented universal basic social protection schemes. To reduce poverty and give immediate access to a basic level of protection, many middle-income countries and a growing number of low-income countries are establishing, or are considering to establish, non-contributory conditional or non-conditional cash transfer schemes for basic income, pension and child benefit schemes.


Extension of coverage by unemployment schemes

Unemployment benefits constitute a key element in any comprehensive social security system. Coupled to the issue of active employment policies, the extension of unemployment insurance is a key investment in both social and economic stability and human capital development.


Establishment and extension of insurance for long-term care

Photo: M. Crozet/ILO

In addition to the general demographic ageing of many populations, the population aged 80 years or over is growing more rapidly than other segments of the older population in most countries. As the financial consequences of the need for care can be substantial for individuals and societies, the establishment or extension of long-term care schemes is an important priority.


Providing access to adequate social security coverage for migrant workers

While migratory flows have increased in the globalized economy, many migrants, and in particular women, are not covered in either their country of employment or their country of origin. Identifying solutions to extending coverage to migrant workers is therefore crucial and will benefit a highly vulnerable group of the world population.


Compliance and contribution collection

Wide population coverage cannot be achieved without appropriate and functioning contribution collection systems, which includes compliance and enforcement. Non-compliance and evasion have serious consequences for the level of protection of scheme members as well as the financial and social legitimacy of social security schemes.


Advocate for the extension of social security coverage at the national political level

In many countries, the development of social security is gaining increasing importance on government agendas, and not least the economic and financial crisis has once again confirmed the importance of social security. In this context, social security institutions have a high potential to advocate for coverage extension at the national political level and to offer their expertise and experience in the policy-making process leading to more effective social security measures and extension outcomes.


The importance of partnerships at the international level

There are a number of international organizations that work towards the extension of social security coverage. First and foremost, the International Labour Office (ILO) has developed the concept of a basic social floor as the way ahead. In the implementation of its strategy, the ISSA will therefore collaborate with international partners and in particular seek to link to and support the activities of the ILO on extension of social protection.


Download:

ISSA strategy for the extension of social security coverage
www.issa.int/Resources/Conference-Reports/ISSA-strategy-for-the-extension-of-social-security-coverage

Social Security Reforms
From Belgium, Canada, The People's Republic of China, Ecuador, France, India, Luxembourg, Mali, Poland, Rwanda, Switzerland, the United States and Zimbabwe.
World map
A selection of recent reforms in social security schemes worldwide compiled by the ISSA Social Security Observatory, with links to a full description of the reforms in the ISSA country profiles.

Social Security Agreement between Belgium and India

This agreement on the one hand permits the cumulation of periods of employment in the two countries to generate retirement and survivors' pension rights, and on the other provides social cover for workers temporarily employed in the other country. It further provides for the payment of retirement and other pensions outside the country without deductions or retentions with the aim of facilitating administrative procedures.

Full article >>
ISSA Country profile: Belgium >>
ISSA Country profile: India >>


Social Security Agreement between Canada and Poland

This agreement permits, on the one hand, the cumulation of periods of employment in the two countries to generate retirement, invalidity and survivors' pension rights, and, on the other, the provision of social cover for workers temporarily employed in the other country, avoiding double contributions. The agreement further provides for the payment of retirement and other pensions outside the country without deductions or retentions with the aim of facilitating administrative procedures.

Full article >>
ISSA Country profile: Canada >>
ISSA Country profile: Poland >>


The People's Republic of China: China’s first social insurance law adopted

The Standing Committee of the National People's Congress (China's top legislature) adopted on 28 October 2010 the country's first and long-awaited Social Insurance Law, which will come into force as of 1 July 2011.

Full article >>
ISSA Country profile: The People's Republic of China >>


Ecuador: National Social Security Agency introduces new sickness and maternity regulations

On 5 July 2010, the governing board of the Ecuadoran Social Security Institute (Instituto Ecuatoriano de la Seguridad Social (IESS)) introduced new regulations governing health and maternity benefits under the obligatory and voluntary regimes of the General Individual and Family Health Insurance (Seguro General de Salud Individual y Familiar).

Full article >>
ISSA Country profile: Ecuador >>


France: Adoption of the draft pension reform bill

Following final adoption of draft legislation concerning pension reform by the Senate on 26 October 2010 and by the National Assembly on 28 October 2010 and the decision of the Constitutional Council of 9 November 2010, the bill on pension reform was promulgated by the President of the Republic and published in the Official Journal dated 10 November 2010.

Full article >>
ISSA Country profile: France >>


Luxembourg: Reform of the health-care system

Draft legislation to reform the health-care system was submitted to Parliament on 6 October 2010. This project reflects the government's desire to preserve a health system based on national solidarity, equity and accessibility as well as the quality of the care provided.

Full article >>
ISSA Country profile: Luxembourg >>


Mali: Progress in the introduction of compulsory health insurance

Preparations continue prior to the introduction of compulsory health insurance (Assurance maladie obligatoire (AMO)). The AMO was established under Act no. 09-015 dated 26 June 2009. The National Health Insurance Fund (Caisse national d'assurance maladie (CANAM)), a public administrative body which operates under the supervision of the Ministry of Social Development, Solidarity and Old People, has been given responsibility for the administration of the AMO.

Full article >>
ISSA Country profile: Mali >>


Social Security Agreement between the United States and Poland

This agreement on the one hand permits the cumulation of periods of employment in the two countries to generate retirement, invalidity and survivors' pension rights, and on the other provides social cover for workers temporarily employed in the other country, avoiding double contributions. The agreement further provides for the payment of retirement and other pensions outside the country without deductions or retentions with the aim of facilitating administrative procedures .

Full article >>
ISSA Country profile: Poland >>
ISSA Country profile: United States >>


Rwanda: Revenue Authority to collect social security contributions

The Rwanda Revenue Authority (RRA) and the Social Security Fund of Rwanda (SSFR) signed a Memorandum of Understanding which would transfer authority for collecting social security contributions, specifically in the first phase for pension and work injury contributions, from the SSFR to the RRA.

Full article >>
ISSA Country profile: Rwanda >>


Switzerland: Unemployment insurance reform

The aim of this new reform is to re-establish the financial equilibrium of the unemployment insurance and to ensure its sustainability by reducing both the structural deficit and the debts accumulated since 2004, estimated at approximately CHF 7 billion at the end of June 2010.

Full article >>
ISSA Country profile: Switzerland >>


Zimbabwe: New monetary reform benefits pension payment system

Following the indefinite suspension of the Zimbabwe dollar in favour of a multicurrency system in February 2009, the National Social Security Authority (NSSA) has introduced a number of changes, which include, among others, embarking on a computerization project to enhance its ICT system.

Full article >>
ISSA Country profile: Zimbabwe >>


More reforms on www.issa.int/reforms

Dynamic Social Security: Securing social stability and economic development
Developments and Trends - Global Report 2010
This new ISSA report confirms the essential role of social security systems as a social and economic stabilizer, and points to the need for heightened innovation and integration to ensure social security’s future sustainability and extension to unprotected populations.

Among the report’s main findings:

- Social security organizations responded effectively to the challenges posed by the recent financial and economic crisis and public support for social security has increased.
- The countries that were most able to manage the impacts of the crisis were those that had comprehensive social security systems already in place, confirming the vital role of social security as a social buffer and economic stabilizer.
- Addressing the challenges posed by growing uncertainty and instability requires new and innovative approaches.
- Social security systems increasingly depend both on contributions and tax revenue to finance programmes. To ensure future financial sustainability, the integrated design and reform of social security programmes and tax systems is essential.
- Social security administrations are increasingly required to be involved in the policy-making process, placing greater emphasis on a holistic approach to the case management of beneficiaries’ needs, and working in partnership with other agencies and services in both the public and private sectors.


Download:

Dynamic Social Security: Securing social stability and economic development
www.issa.int/dt-global2010

World Social Security Report 2010/11
New International Labour Office publication
The World Social Security Report 2010/11 examines the scope, extent, levels and quality of coverage by various social security branches and the scale of countries’ investments in social security, measured by the size and structure of social security expenditure and the sources of its financing. The thematic focus is the nature of social security responses to the financial and economic crisis.

The report clearly shows that the majority of the world population still has no access to comprehensive social security systems. Thus, to prepare global society for future economic downturns and to achieve other global objectives such as the Millennium Development Goals, sustainable economic development and a fair globalization, a fundamental task is to develop comprehensive social security systems in countries where only rudimentary systems exist so far, starting with the provision of basic income security and affordable access to essential health care to all in need: a global social protection floor. Based on that floor, higher levels of social security should then be sought as economies develop and the fiscal space for redistributive policies widens.


Download and additional information (external site):

World Social Security Report 2010/11
http://www.ilo.org/global/publications/ilo-bookstore/order-online/books/WCMS_146566/lang--en/index.htm

Major ISSA Event 2011
In 2011, the ISSA is co-organizing the following major event:
XIX World Congress on Safety and Health
11.09.2011 - 15.09.2011 | Istanbul, Turkey

The 8th International Film and Multimedia Festival is an integral part of the XIX World Congress on Safety and Health at Work.


World Congress >>

More information on upcoming ISSA events >>

Information on other social security events >>

© ISSA 2008-2013. All rights reserved.
ISSN 2070-2698
Contact us | Terms and conditions

International Social Security Association
4 route des Morillons | Case postale 1 | CH-1211 Geneva 22 | www.issa.int
T: +41 22 799 66 17 | F: +41 22 799 85 09 | E: issa@ilo.org